NORTH KINGSTOWN SCHOOL COMMITTEE

Wednesday, February 25, 2004

7:00 PM Business Meeting

North Kingstown High School                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               150 Fairway Drive, North Kingstown

“Challenging Student Excellence”

Minutes

 

The Level III Grievance scheduled for 6:00 pm this evening was cancelled.   

 

I.      Pledge of Allegiance   

 

II.      Call To Order            The meeting was called to order by Don DeFedele at 7:03 pm.

Roll Call                Present:  Chairperson Don DeFedele, Vice Chairperson Dr. Denise Coppa, Carol

Hueston, Barry Martasian, Bill Mudge, Kevin Mulvey, Patricia Watkins, and Cathy Kaiser, Jamestown School Committee Representative

                               

                Administration Present:  James M. Halley, Ed.D; Superintendent of Schools; Barbara

                A. Fitzsimmons, Ed.D, Curriculum Director; Joseph F. Quinn, Jr., Director of

                Administrative Services, William J. Daly, Director of Human Resources; and Maureen

                Buck, Controller;

                                Absent:  Daniel J. McGregor, Ph.D., Director of Pupil Personnel Services

                                               

III.      Contract Signing            NEA/NK and the North Kingstown School Department

·         Union President, Robert Sullivan and School Committee Chairperson, Donald DeFedele each signed a one (1) year and a three (3) year teacher’s contract, the one year contract is for 2003-2004, and the three year contract is for 2004-2007.

 

IV.      Open Forum

  • Julie Rishworth spoke regarding the new Kindergarten policy.  Dismayed that children who are born after September 1 will not be grandfathered in.  She and her husband were told in December that these children would be grandfathered into school, and they made plans accordingly.  Now all has changed, and they don’t know where to turn.  
  • April Brunelle is outraged that Open Forum will be taken out of the Worksession meetings.  She questioned if the School Committee is afraid of what the public might have to say.
  • James Moniz also spoke regarding the new Kindergarten policy.  He stated that he felt that the solution would be to apply early entrance based on age.  He also mentioned that he would appeal a denial by the school department to RIDE.  He also feels that the denials are “inflexible and mean spirited.”
  • After reading a statement written by Lynda Avenzato regarding her disapproval of the removal of Open Forum from School Committee Worksessions, Kathy Brown stated that she felt that there was no need for the School Committee to vote on the religious holidays which were on the agenda as Dr. Halley had, rightly, already placed them on the School Calendar.   She would like the School Committee to revisit the subject of Good Friday being a “holiday”.
  • Robert Sullivan held that a citizen wanting to place an item on the School Committee’s agenda “must go through bureaucracy in order to do so”.  He also felt that excluding the Open Forum from Worksessions would be “perceived as a method of controlling the audience”.  In addition, Mr. Sullivan asked that the School Committee look at moving the February 2005 vacation as it generally falls in the third week of that month and not the fourth.  People may already have standing plans made.

 

V.      Routine Items

 

A.                  Disclosure of  Executive Session Votes

·         January 21, 2004:  Motion to grant a grievance concerning the assignment of counselors at the middle school level.  The motion was defeated 4 to 1 with Dr. Coppa voting in favor.

·         February 11, 2004:  Motion regarding job fair participation; the motion passed unanimously to uphold the administration’s position.

 

B.                   Correspondence and Good News

·         Barry Martasian stated that he received three emails regarding the new Kindergarten policy and an invitation to the Family Services of RI Open House on March 29th at 10:00 am.

·         Pat Watkins thanked the School Department for her complimentary ticket to the NKHS production of Cinderella on March 12-14th.

·         Carol Hueston mentioned the presentation by Blue Cross Blue Shield of RI entitled the “Part of the Solution Forum” at the Crowne Plaza.

·         Don DeFedele brought up the Davisville Middle School’s Salt Survey and said that they deserved congratulations for a job well done.  He also received emails regarding the new Kindergarten policy and consideration of the Jewish holidays as days off from school.

 

C.                   Calendars – Dr. Halley went over the calendar for the next two weeks with the School Committee, and the committee decided which dates were best for which members to visit the schools’ PTO meetings to discuss the budget. (Appendix A)

 

 CONSENT AGENDA

Approved items on the consent agenda are marked with * on a motion by Pat Watkins and seconded by Carol Hueston.  The motion carried with all in favor except Bill Mudge who abstained from voting.

Approved items that were exempted or amended within the consent agenda are marked with ** as indicated immediately following the item.

Withdrawn or Tabled Items from the consent agenda are marked with *** as indicated immediately following the item.

 

D.                  Approval of Minutes of Prior Meetings*

 

1.        January 7, Executive Session Minutes**

2.        January 21, Business Meeting Minutes

3.        February 9, Budget Worksession Minutes

4.        February 10, Budget Worksession Minutes

1.        February 11, Worksession Minutes**

** Mr. Martasian had minor questions which were quickly answered.  There was no need for the minutes to be amended.

 

E.                   Financial Reports*

 

1.        Financial Reports Overview

2.        Monthly Deficit Monitoring Report

3.        Year to Date Expenditure Report 

 

F.                   Bids and Awards *

 

1.         Change Order

a)       Additional costs for the Replacement of Fishing Cove Elementary School Roof

    

G.                   Personnel Items*

 

1.                    Appointments, Certificated Staff:

 

a)                   Kara Osborne, .2 FTE Social Studies Teacher at the North Kingstown High School, Step 1, pro-rated for 97 days in the 2003/2004 school year with a total of $3422.16, effective January 26, 2004 – budgeted.

b)                   William Dwyer, 1.0 FTE Music Teacher at Stony Lane Elementary School, Step 1, pro-rated for 93 days in the 2003/2004 school year with a total salary of $16,407.06, effective February 2, 2004 – budgeted.

 

c)                   Sharon McCarthy, .6 FTE Family & Consumer Science Teacher at the North Kingstown High School, Step 1, pro-rated for 93 days in the 2003/2004 school year with a total salary of $9844.05, effective February 2, 2004 –budgeted.

 

2.                    Appointment, Non-Certificated Staff:

 

a)                   Karin Pierson, Mini Bus Driver for the North Kingstown School Department, Step 1 @ $69.19 per day, effective February 2, 2004 – budgeted.

 

3.                    Resignations, Non-Certificated Staff:

 

a)                   Judy Fry, Special Education Paraprofessional at Forest Park Elementary School, 6 hours per day, effective January 23, 2004.

 

b)                   Gail Burda, Adult Education Director, effective January 30, 2004.

 

 

END OF CONSENT AGENDA

 

VI.      New Business

VII.      Unfinished Business

 

A.   Consideration of Closing Schools for Religious Holidays for Vote

·         Kevin Mulvey stated that this item was placed on the agenda at his request at the last meeting.  He felt at the time that the item should be considered a separate item from the school calendar because he was fearful the Jewish holidays would be on the school calendar for only one year.  However, he has “rethought this matter, because no other holiday is so designated.”

·         Don DeFedele added that he did not disagree, however he wanted to make sure that the holiday stays on the calendar; if the committee “does not vote this may not continue.”

·         Mr. Mulvey then stated that perhaps all holidays should be named and voted on.

·         Pat Watkins reminded the committee that some holidays are contract driven, and advised that the policy subcommittee was the best solution for the problem.  She then motioned to move the subject to the policy subcommittee.  Carol Hueston seconded the motion which passed with a unanimous vote.

 

B.    Consideration of NKHS Math Proposal for Vote

·         Kevin Mulvey wanted to add his congratulations on a job well done to Vice Principal John Lalli, to those given by his colleagues at the last Worksession regarding this topic.

·         Pat Watkins motioned to accept the NKHS Math Proposal.  Carol Hueston seconded the motion which passed with a unanimous vote.

 

C.       Consideration of School Calendar for Vote

·         Denise Coppa stated that it did not make sense to change the February vacation from the fourth week back to the third week, and have the vacation end with Presidents Day which is the Monday of the fourth week.

·         Dr. Halley agreed, and stated that the school department follows state recommendations for holidays and vacations when developing the calendar.

·         Pat Watkins motioned to approve the school calendar and Carol Hueston seconded.  The motion passed unanimously.

·         Bill Mudge asked Dr. Halley when he thought Professional Development days would be announced.  Dr. Halley responded that the days would be known before the first day of school.

 

              D.    Minutes of School Committee Meeting for Discussion and Action

·         Don DeFedele mentioned that at the February Worksession it had been stated that the distribution of the School Committee minutes should not be distributed until after they are approved at Business Meetings.

·         Barry Martasian clarified that if a citizen wanted to read the minutes prior to their being approved, they simply needed to come to the administration building and request a copy for review.

·         Mr. DeFedele agreed and stated that the copies were merely no longer going to be dispensed to the schools and others until after they were approved in case there were amendments that needed to be made.

·         Carol Hueston asked if each and every page was going to state that it was an “unapproved” copy.

·         Mr. DeFedele instructed the School Committee secretary to indicate in the background of each page that it is a “DRAFT” copy.

·         Pat Watkins motioned to approve the changes for School Committee Meeting Minutes distribution.  Carol Hueston seconded the motion which passed with a unanimous vote.

 

E.    Policies

1.  NSBA #JFA Initial Admission to North Kingstown School District (Replaces JEB and JEB-R) (Appendix B)

·         Kevin Mulvey motioned to approve the policy and Denise Coppa seconded the motion.

·         Pat Watkins mentioned that there were already petitions before the administration, formal requests for an appeal to a policy which the School Committee had not even adopted yet.

·         Don DeFedele agreed, and stated that Kindergarten registration had yet to take place.

·         Dr. Halley said that in order to appeal there must be a decision; whatever rules apply after April 29th, after Kindergarten registration.

·         Mr. Mudge stated that the policy change gives no latitude for an appeal.

·         Dr. Halley replied that anyone can always request an appeal by simply writing a letter, that is the school department policy.

·         Kevin Mulvey stated that parents must look for an exception to the policy for their appeal.

·         Mr. Mulvey’s motion passed with a vote of 6 to 1, Bill Mudge voting “No”.

 

2.        NSBA #BE School Committee Meetings  (Appendix C)

·         Kevin Mulvey motioned to adopt the policy and Denise Coppa seconded this motion.

·         Don DeFedele declared that “Open Forum” is removed from the Worksession only because the public can speak after each agenda item.  There is a “Citizens Comments” section for the community to speak on any topic at the end of every meeting.  The sign up sheet was initiated out of time constraints and consistency, “not to stifle the public”.  As for the community wanting to place items on the agenda, School Committee members must also give their suggestions to the Chairperson or Superintendent 14 days in advance.

·         Carol Hueston reminded the committee that Mrs. Lynne Haft, the previous Chairperson, was fond of saying that “School Committee meetings are not public meetings, but meetings in public”.

·         Bill Mudge objected to the removal of “Open Forum” from the Worksession meetings, and suggested that the committee seek legal counsel prior to implementing this policy.  He also stated that he opposed having the community contact the superintendent or chairperson two weeks prior to having something placed on an agenda.

·         Don DeFedele responded that the public is often contacting him to place items on the agenda.  If he tells them that he will not place what they want on an agenda, citizens have every right to contact the rest of the committee and obtain a consensus.  Mr. DeFedele went on to say that that he had obtained several emails requesting more structure at meetings.  People attend meetings and because the “Open Forum” at some meetings can take some time, these people can wait hours before the topic they came to hear discussed is ever reached.

·         Mr. Mudge stated that with the loss of “Open Forum” at Worksessions, the public cannot feel free to come to meetings and speak early.

·         The motion passed with a vote of 6 to 1, Bill Mudge voting “No”.

 

F.    Consideration of 2004-05 School Budget for Vote

·         Kevin Mulvey made a motion to accept the Superintendent’s $49,281,642.00 budget.  Denise Coppa seconded the motion.

·         Bill Mudge asked, in reference to the 5.9% increase, if the amount included all anticipated Title 19 services.

·         Maureen Buck responded negatively.

·         Dr. Halley stated that some items are budgeted and are included in the amendment to the budget such as administrative costs.

·         This discussion continued further with the same question being asked by Mr. Mudge about the 2003-04 budget and the 2002-03 budget.  He received the same response.  Dr. Halley tried to give Mr. Mudge a detailed explanation, but he interrupted and asked for it in writing.

·         Mr. Mulvey’s motion passed with a vote of 6 to 1, Bill Mudge voting “No”.

·         Mr. Mudge then made a motion to cut $2.1 million from the Superintendent’s Budget.  This motion did not receive a second.

 

G.    School Modernization Implementation

·         Don DeFedele brought the list of appointments to the new School Modernization Advisory Committee to the attention of the committee (Appendix D)

·         Pat Watkins motioned to accept the appointments and Carol Hueston seconded the motion.  The motion passed with a vote of 6 to 1.  Bill Mudge voted against the motion stating that he was not objecting to the people on the new committee, but rather to the bond issue that would be necessary to realize the school modernizations.

 

H.    2003-04 Budget

·         Bill Mudge asked where the $323,429.00 surplus from the 2002-03 budget had been applied to the 2003-04 budget.

·         Don DeFedele asked if that weren’t a Town function.

·         Dr. Halley stated that indeed it is a Town function, and the amount is paid back to the general fund.

·         Mr. DeFedele stated that it is the starting point for the next year’s budget.

·         Dr. Halley mentioned that there is an explanation to that effect in the current budget.

·         Mr. DeFedele remarked that he had received a copy, as had the rest of the committee, of a transmission to Mrs. Buck regarding the audit of that budget stating that there were no findings which required further action.

 

I.     2003-04 Goals and Objectives 

·         There is a KeyWorks meeting scheduled for March 18, 2004 in the Administration Building.

 

VIII.      Reports

 

   A.    Completed Security Reports

·         Kevin Mulvey expressed his dismay with the expensive damage at the high school.  He stated he had yet to see a worse report.

·         Dr. Halley replied that it has been an issue since the high school has been open.  Partly due to the students during the day and partly due to the fact that the school is well used after hours.  He continued by saying that he and Mr. Quinn had discussed hiring security.

·         Mr. Quinn acknowledged that the building does receive incredible use each day with proportional vandalism.  He said that the answer is to improve supervision, “but hiring hall monitors costs money”.  He stated that it was unfortunate that security cameras were not installed when the school was built.  Mr. Quinn informed the committee that where the vandals can be identified, they are billed.

·         Mr. Mulvey felt that the security reports should be sent home to parents to impress them and the students with the numbers and cost, and perhaps embarrass the students into taking more pride in their school.

·         Mr. Mudge asked if it would be possible to add a time stamp to the report that would indicate exactly when the incidents take place.

·         Mr. Quinn replied that he would see to it.

 

   B.     Subcommittee Reports

·         Barry Martasian announced that a meeting had been scheduled for March 2, 2004 at 9:30 am in the Central Administration Building for the Community Relations Subcommittee.

 

C.         RIASC and other Legislative Activity

·         Kevin Mulvey announced that RIASC will be holding a legislative workshop on Saturday, March 13, 2004 from 9:00 am to noon.  He explained the premise of the meeting whereby each piece of new education legislation is described along with the probability of it passing.

 

IX.      Comments

 

·         Dr. Halley:  “I just wanted the School Committee to know, at Mr. Mudge’s request, that Representative Carter is inquiring into the appropriateness of our school housing aid all the way back to 1985.”

·         Bill Mudge:  “Gee, I wish I knew that.  Excuse me, Dr. Halley, you misspoke.  He’s not doing it because I asked him to do that.  Let the record reflect that clearly.  Mr. Carter is not, ok, going back to request information back to 1985 because Bill Mudge asked him to do that, or was Bill Mudge aware of that.  Thank you; please be specific.”

·         Pat Watkins:  “Mr. Carter is not here to…”

·         Bill Mudge:  “Well I’m here, and I’m telling you that I didn’t tell him or ask him to go back and get that data, so you don’t need Mr. Carter here.”

·         Don DeFedele:  “It is in the record.”

·         Julie Rishworth stated that she wrote a letter to Dr. Daniel McGregor regarding her son who was born after the September 1st cut off date for Kindergarten.  In response, Dr. McGregor stated that there was no point in appealing

·         Don DeFedele advised Mrs. Rishworth to appeal under the new policy.

·         Mr. Adrian Rishworth requested advice on how to accomplish that.

·         Dr. Halley replied that the Rishworths should write to the school department with an appeal for an individual exception.

·         Korrine Erickson spoke regarding the new Kindergarten policy and parental confusion.  She stated that the school department and School Committee deal with the policy and regulations daily, and asked that they remember that parents are perplexed and to please be gentle with them.

·         Ellen Jordan thanked the committee for hearing her concerns regarding considering Jewish holidays as days off from school, and voting to recognize this as an addition to the school calendar.

 

 

X.      Adjourn

 

  • Motion to adjourn was made by Pat Watkins and seconded by Carol Hueston at 9:35 pm, 2:32:08:16.  There were no home schooling, negotiations, or personnel matters for School Committee members to attend to so they did not adjourn to Executive Session.

 

 

                                                                                               

 

                                                                                                Respectfully submitted,

 

 

                                                                                                _______________________________________

                                                                                                Konnie M. Mazur

                                                                                                School Committee Secretary

                                                                                                Approved March 24, 2004

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

NORTH KINGSTOWN SCHOOL COMMITTEE

 

Wednesday, February 25, 2004

 

7:00 PM Business Meeting

 

 

BUSINESS AGENDA ADDENDUM

 

 

V.G.                         4.             Appointment Administrator:

 

a)                   Kathleen Mort, Ed. D., Principal at Wickford Middle

School, with an annual salary of $91,909, effective July, 1, 2004 – budgeted.

 

5.                    Resignation, Administrator:

 

a)                   Tyler Page, Principal at Wickford Middle School, effective        

June 30, 2004.

 

 

  • Bill Mudge was interested to know when this job was posted, and if the public was ever made aware of it.  He wanted to know if it had ever been advertised.  He was curious as to why the School Committee was not in on the decision making process.
  • Pat Watkins replied that personnel matters come repeatedly before the committee without their receiving prior notification.
  • Mr. Mudge felt that their may be qualified people in the community who could fill this position, but did not get the opportunity to apply.
  • Kevin Mulvey pointed out that personnel matters come as recommendations of the administration for approval.  Mr. Mudge has the right to approve them or not.
  • Dr. Halley interjected that the faculty of Wickford Middle School is positive in their recommendations of this appointment as is the SAC.
  • Bill Mudge would like to know why the school department does not advertise these job openings.
  • Personnel Director, Bill Daly, stated that the reason this opening was not advertised was because “we have an excellent person” already in house.
  • Mr. Mudge insisted that there may be someone else in the public who would also suit.
  • Mr. Daly stated that the Wickford Middle School community wanted this appointment.
  • Pat Watkins motioned to approve this addendum to the agenda.  Carol Hueston seconded the motion which passed with a vote of 6 to 1, Bill Mudge opposing.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix A

 

 

PTO MEETINGS

 

 

SCHOOL

DATE

TIME

DON

DENISE

KEVIN

CAROL

BILL

PAT

BARRY

 

High School

April 27

7:00 PM

 

X

 

X

 

X

 

 

DMS

March 25

6:30 PM

 

X

X

 

 

X

 

 

WMS

March 9

7:00 PM

 

 

 

 

X

X

X

 

DE

March 11

3:15 PM

 

 

X

 

 

X

X

 

FC

March 16

7:00 PM

 

 

 

X

 

X

 

X

FP

March 11

7:00 PM

 

 

X

 

X

X

 

 

HE

March 2

9:45 AM

 

X

 

 

X

X

 

 

QE

March 9

6:30 PM

 

 

 

X

 

X

 

X

SL

March 16

7:00 PM

 

 

 

 

 

X

X

 

WE

March 8

7:00 PM

 

X

 

 

 

X